The Inquirer-Home

Iocell Netdisk 351UNE

Review Flexible external storage unit
Wed Jan 20 2010, 16:12




Product: Iocell Netdisk 351UNE
Website: www.iocellnetworks.com
Specifications: 3.5-inch SATA bay, eSATA, USB 2.0, Ethernet (NDAS), 161x213x48mm, 567g
Price: £249.99 (1TB)


BURGEONING COLLECTIONS of digital media and the rise of the home network have resulted in an ever-increasing demand for extra storage space, and with large file sizes being bandied around, transfer speeds could do with a shot in the arm as well.

Luckily the industry is delivering, and rarely in such an attractive fashion than Iocell and its Netdisk 351UNE. Sporting the very latest in high-speed connectivity, it offers eSATA and USB2.0 for direct connection and most importantly, NDAS technology for accessing files at high speeds over a network.

351une-1NDAS, or Network Direct Attached Storage, is a proprietary technology developed by Ximeta, with software drivers for Windows typically provided by device vendors like Iocell or - for Unix-like operating systems such as Linux and Mac OS X - available directly from Ximeta. In a nutshell, NDAS bypasses the TCP/IP protocol layer at both the source and destination, which makes for easier setup but more importantly faster speeds – up to six times faster than NAS in fact, according to claims.

The Netdisk device itself sports a tidy, angular design, houses a SATA drive and is available at up to 2TB capacities or enclosure-only. Setup under Microsoft Windows on a network is predictably quite straightforward, requiring a short software installation that uses a wizard to register a unique security key and mount the drive in the desired mode. After this initial setup, a small system tray utility grants access to security settings and the ability to view users currently accessing the hardware. It can then be hooked up to a router via the Ethernet port to grant wireless access to a LAN and for future expansion, multi-disk configurations allow up to eight drives linked in a RAID 0 array.

Users who don’t already have their own backup software will find a range of solutions supplied, including Syncbackpro and SE, Onclick and Infohesive, so everything from backup and restore to organising, encrypting and searching large collections is available out of the box.

Of course the real appeal of the Netdisk 351UNE would be its ‘lightning fast speeds’, and we were eager to take it for a spin to see if it could live up to it’s billing.

We ran a series of tests by transferring varied collections of files in 1GB, 2GB and 10GB packages to and from the drive over each of the connections, and turned up some pretty impressive results.

USB 2.0 speeds were as you’d expect, delivering an average of around 25MBps for both read and write times. Transfers on eSata were predictably the fastest, averaging 59MBps in the write tests and 56MBps for read tests. Copying over a network via NDAS fell somewhere in between – 34MBps write and 32MBps read.

Now, these results are some way below the quoted 100MBps maximum, but bear in mind that these are average times for random read and writes of varied collections of files to reflect the drive’s real-world capabilities, so in this light we were quite pleased with the results.

In addition we also copied a few 1080p video files onto the drive and threw them across a wireless connection to a media streamer in another room and were pleased to note almost flawless playback – all but indistinguishable, in fact, from the streamer’s performance with the same files when stored locally.

351une-2Iocell certainly seems to be onto a winner with the Netdisk 351UNE then, and though the MSRP is a little higher than we expected it’s worth noting that at the time of writing, the drive could be picked up online for an astonishing £60 (enclosure only) or as low as £120 for the 1TB model if you shop around. Our only real gripes are that there's no dedicated media connectivity to cut out the need for an additional device such as a media streamer - since one of its purposes was listed as storing HD video content, audio/video connectivity on the device would have been a bonus - and no built-in wireless, but at this price we really can’t feel too aggrieved.

In Short
We’re not sure about Iocell’s “world’s fastest” claims, but the Netdisk offers high capacity storage and high speeds with a minimum of fuss. The 351UNE model opens up some impressive new technology to those who need to add storage to a home or office network at an attractive price. µ

The Good
High speeds, great deals available online.

The Bad
Lack of media connectivity.

The Ugly
No built-in wireless.

Bartender’s Score
8/10

beer8

Share this:

Comments
@Believer

re: iSCSI, never heard of either FreeBSD or OpenSolaris?

That said, I don't understand these single-disk-on-a-LAN solutions at all. Where are people finding them useful?

posted by : A. Peon, 22 January 2010 Complain about this comment
Remind me...

...when did USB 2.0 become "the very latest in high-speed connectivity"?

Oh yes, I remember ... 2000.

Wake me up when it supports 3.0. Tea, white, two sugars, ta.

posted by : Jon Green, 22 January 2010 Complain about this comment
Need To Update Ripped Off Content

Price: £110 (no drive), £250 (1TB), £300 (1.5TB), £400 (2TB)

Not £60 for enclosure only

posted by : NeedToUpdateRippedOffContent, 21 January 2010 Complain about this comment
NAS vs NDAS

These devices are great, depending on the application you're using them in, Hannes is right, no set top media box can access them, but most people serious about their entertainment are using HTPC's anyway, so its a moot point.

To offset Hannes's point, they have an advantage that NAS doesn't, the ability to schedule regular backup's on Vista and Win7 using the builtin backup utility. which is why i bought my first one. they provide an affordable alternative to iSCSI, which isnt cheap or even reasonable to purchase in a home setting.

They have more fine grained comtrol over user access that most NAS boxes do, and unlike NAS boxes you arent limited to the internal drive capacity of the unit. you can easily stack units as the author pointed out, up to 8 units and configure them in various raid, spanned or JOBD configurations.

This review only covers the single drive enclosures, IOCell offers 1 2 and 5 disk SOHO enclosures, 5 and 8 disk SMB towers and 8 16 and 24 disk enterprise rackmount rigs.

This technology isnt new, i got my first NDAS 3 years ago, but its definitely got a future as it continues to mature.

posted by : Believer, 21 January 2010 Complain about this comment
It's okay...

I've been using one for about a year. The technology is good for people looking for an inexpensive alternative to Apple's Time Capsule. As for the security and transfer protocol, it's debatable.

Does what it claims to and that's all that I asked.

posted by : Integr8d, 20 January 2010 Complain about this comment
NDAS vs. NAS

well, so you're suggesting putting the 1080p collection on these things... and then? no media player/tank on the world (popcorn, xtreamer, WDTV, etc) can access these IOCELL NDAS things! for every computer on a network that wants to access files on an iocell, I have to install proprietary drivers and software? nah thanks, forget it, this technology is dead in the water.

posted by : Hannes The Hun, 20 January 2010 Complain about this comment
aboutus
Advertisement
Subscribe to INQ newsletters
Advertisement
INQ Poll

Authorities in several countries raided Megaupload recently, shut down all of its services, seized hundreds of servers and arrested several of its executives on criminal charges.

Do you think the move was justified?