The Inquirer-Home

Google to flag links removed following 'right to be forgotten' ruling

But decision already slammed for not addressing legal issues
Mon Jun 09 2014, 10:12
Google logo

GOOGLE REPORTEDLY plans to flag links that it censors due to Europe's recent "right to be forgotten" ruling.

That's according to The Guardian, which reported that Google plans to place an alert at the bottom of each page where it has removed links, after the European Court of Jutice (ECJ) ruled last month that users can request that "inadequate, irrelevant or no longer relevant" links be taken down.

It's unclear exactly how this will look, but the report claimed that Google might flag results similar to the way it does illegal content, such as copyright infringing material.

"For example, a Google search for 'Adele MP3' shows that it has removed a number of results from that page after receiving complaints under the US Digital Millennium Copyright Act," The Guardian noted.

Jodie Ginsberg, chief executive of Index on Censorship said that while flagging search results is all well and good, it does nothing to fix the legal issues surrounding the recent ECJ ruling.

She said, "The fact that Google plans to add 'flags' to search links it has removed does nothing to tackle the fundamental problem with the 'right to be forgotten' ruling - which is the complete absence of legal oversight in this process.

"We remain deeply concerned about a ruling that opens the door to a censoring of the past without any proper checks and balances."

This isn't the only negative reaction the ECJ ruling has received. The Article 29 European watchdog admitted last week that it doesn't know yet how to handle complaints related to the ruling, with the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) also admitting that it needs more time to figure it out.

Google chairman Eric Schmidt isn't pleased about it, either, slamming the "right to be forgotten" ruling as "wrong".

Google reportedly received 12,000 completed takedown forms on the day it published its response to the ECJ's "right to be forgotten" ruling, and as of last week had racked up a total of 41,000.

Google has declined to comment on the report. µ


Share this:

blog comments powered by Disqus
Subscribe to INQ newsletters

Sign up for INQbot – a weekly roundup of the best from the INQ

INQ Poll

Microsoft Windows 10 poll

Which feature of Windows 10 are you most excited about?