The Inquirer-Home

HP support fails woman with monitor problems

Recommends using a man
Mon Dec 05 2011, 11:31

FLOGGER OF EXPENSIVE PRINTER INK HP has been accused of letting down a woman who turned to it for help with her monitor.

"Can a man help?" was the unfortunate and rather inappropriate response given to the woman who, as a reader of the Consumerist web site, decided to go public with what happened.

However the phone call ended, which in this case was the suggestion that she get some male assistance, none of it sounds particularly helpful.

"I was transferred to E., a customer service representative. I briefly explained my problem, and he started asking me to press buttons on the monitor. I explained that I don't think this is the issue, but he asked me to 'do him a favor and try anyway'," says the Consumerist reader named Tara.

"After five minutes of pressing buttons, I stated, 'I don't think you understand the nature of my problem. The monitor won't raise to the full-height position. In the manual, it says to press down on the display head to unlock it then pull up on the display head to raise it to the full-height position. I tried this, and it won't raise any higher.' E. apologized for not understanding me in the first place, and told me he got it now. He asked if he could place me on hold for two minutes."

These two minutes turned into five minutes, says the disgruntled shopper, and when it finished lead to some rather hands-on advice.

"E. picked up the phone and told me to press down on the monitor and try to lift it to the full-height position. 'I read that, too,' I said. 'That's what I've been doing.' He told me to 'try harder.' Fine. I tried again. I put the monitor on the floor and even stepped on it while I tried to pull it up. He said, 'Try as hard as you can, you can't break it this way.' I do it multiple times, slamming the monitor up and down, and nothing. I say, 'It is not working. I think it is defective.'"

Then, perhaps because he sensed that Tara did not have the strength required to make an HP monitor extend to its highest position, 'E' suggested that she give up and get someone else to do it. That someone being a man.

"E. says, 'Is there someone more technically savvy in your office or maybe a man that can try?'" Tara reported. "Excuse me? He asked me to find a man to help me with my problem? Thanks, E., for sending the women's movement back about 80 years."

We've asked HP to comment on this report and will update if we get a response. µ

Share this:

Comments
Some people are born to be offended

The tech support rep set women's rights back? Really?

posted by : THE OUTRAGE!, 06 December 2011 Complain about this comment
What stupidity by all involved including The Inquirer

I mean really...

First is this really news worthy?

Second if the woman was foolish enough to bang the monitor on the floor three times, she probably ain't smart enough to be operating a PC because she might hurt herself or someone else.

Third, maybe the moron tech in India didn't understand that the woman was a WWF female wrestler or he would not have suggested asking a stronger person in the office to assist.

Stupidity abounds in society.

posted by : Don, 05 December 2011 Complain about this comment
Redundant article title

The title is "HP support fails woman with monitor problems."

You do not need both "HP support" and "fails" to complete the thought; the terms and synonymous.

posted by : Morely the IT Guy, 05 December 2011 Complain about this comment
Shocked! Outraged! Alert the Media...

...or the mighty muckrakers at the Inquirer! Yawn... No response from HP? No wonder. They are being nice. An appropriate response would be to !@#$-off. Seriously. Nothing here to see folks, move on. Have a nice day.

posted by : Dawg Boyd, 05 December 2011 Complain about this comment
I'm not suprised

There was no harm done asking her to let someone stronger give it a try. But she had to take it the wrong way because she was brought up to think male/female are equal in every way. She needs a "time out" to get her head on straight.

posted by : Eric, 05 December 2011 Complain about this comment
These are some strange comments

I can hardly believe the first comments are in defense of HP here. No matter how you slice it they dropped the ball. Here are the potential interpretations I see:

1. HP shipped a broken product
2. HP designed a product that is virtually unusable and need to look for better engineers and usability researchers
3. HP hired a useless tech support person and somehow managed not to notice this at any point in the training process
4. All of the above

posted by : imposter, 05 December 2011 Complain about this comment
Unfortunate choice of words

I'd say its an unfortunate choice of words and probably should have asked if there was anyone else how could try.

I assume she must had a monitor like the HP one I have at work ... when it is unpacked it is folded back on the stand so screen is horizontal and has to be pulled forward to a vertical position to use ... and I definitely recall it takes a serious amount of effort to move and took me some time to do as I was thinking I was about to break it.

posted by : David, 05 December 2011 Complain about this comment
Very Lame...

HP did nothing men are physically stronger than women the guy wanted to help her she should be thanking HP

posted by : James, 05 December 2011 Complain about this comment
aboutus
Advertisement
Subscribe to INQ newsletters
Advertisement
INQ Poll

Facebook starts selling shares

Will you buy Facebook shares?