The Inquirer-Home

HTC files a lawsuit against Apple with Google's patents

Palm and Openwave lend their hands
Thu Sep 08 2011, 09:28

TAIWANESE SMARTPHONE MAKER HTC has fired its latest shot at Apple in the smartphone patent wars using patents that Google obtained last week.

HTC has been in a bitter and prolonged battle with Apple over smartphone patents allegedly infringed by its Android devices. Even though Apple didn't name Google directly in its lawsuit, most observers heralded the fight as one between Apple and Google. Now it seems Google has effectively lent HTC a hand by giving HTC access to its patent portfolio to defend itself.

Bloomberg reports that HTC has filed infringement claims against Apple using nine patents that Google obtained just last week. The patents originally came from Palm, Motorola and Openwave Systems, but US Patent and Trademark Office records show that ownership was changed to Google on 1 September.

HTC filed its lawsuit with the US District Court in Delaware claiming that Apple is infringing four of those patents. Separately, HTC has amended a complaint with the US International Trade Commission alleging that Apple is infringing three patents first issued to Openwave and two originating from Palm.

Although these patents have nothing to do with Google's proposed buyout of Motorola Mobility, it highlights just how important it is for Google to have a competitive patent portfolio in order to back up device manufacturers against Oracle, Apple and Microsoft. If Google can protect Android device makers with its stash of patents then the $12.5bn price tag on Motorola might turn out to be something of a bargain.

If Google's patents have merit then it is likely that Samsung won't wait too long before requesting access to them in order to stop Apple from obtaining import bans on its Galaxy tablets and smartphones all over the world. µ

Share this:

Comments
Just give the facts. I'll decide!!

How does Apple REALLY feel about virtues?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nK7TQVFSA1Y
Must be a misunderstanding, right? Umm NO! Look. http://www.old-computers.com/history/detail.asp?n=44&t=3
Apple
WHAT.. Need MORE, Apple FANBOI? You're a GLUTTON for punishment. See Apple wants to throw stones. But forgets HISTORY is unforgiving. Apple is proven to STEAL as well as LIE ( Perjury?) in court to delay SERIOUS competition. Here: http://techcrunch.com/2011/08/15/apples-evidence-in-european-galaxy-tab-injunction-was-seriously-misleading-as-in-false/#comment-box
This is History this is FACT!!Like JOBS said APPLE IS SHAMELESS!!!!

posted by : Worried, 12 September 2011 Complain about this comment
Google/MS

It seems that a lot of people nowadays think that Google is just as bad as Microsoft and ther might actually be something valid behind that argument.

Both have ultimately the same goal, which is to make money to shareholders. They just have two completely different approaches. Google is very open minded and actually has some principles they follow (e.g. when they left China because of censorship etc.). Microsoft on the other hand is solely focusing on holding its monopolies and making money -- that's it.

Microsoft has no principles whereas Google has vastly advanced the Open Source movement and taken strong stances on various sensitive subjects.

posted by : VAL, 08 September 2011 Complain about this comment
Go Apple

I hope Apple totally screws the asians as the far easterners have dominated the market for far too long.

posted by : The American Communist, 08 September 2011 Complain about this comment
Bravo Google,HTC, Boo Apple!

Apple deserves to be treated the same way it treats others.
Hope Apple crashes and Burns.
Pretending to be an innovator when its really a troll.
Trolls steal ideas then whne it accidentally makes a hit, claims those ideas were all theirs.
Hope Google, HTC et al beat the Fruit Bully and Apple gets juiced very badly.

posted by : Bong, 08 September 2011 Complain about this comment
aboutus
Advertisement
Subscribe to INQ newsletters
Advertisement
INQ Poll

Facebook starts selling shares

Will you buy Facebook shares?