The Inquirer-Home

Scottish filesharer gets three years probation

First conviction in Scotland
Tue May 31 2011, 16:05

A SCOTTISH COURT has sentenced a woman to a term of probation for illegal onlne filesharing.

Anne Muir, a 58 year old nurse from Ayr, is the first person in Scotland to be convicted for illegal filesharing of music. The Sheriff's Court in Ayr sentenced Muir to three years probation.

Muir was charged with distributing £54,000 worth of copyrighted music files and pleaded guilty earlier this month. She admitted to having made the music tracks available online using a peer-to-peer file sharing application.

Her filesharing activities were uncovered in an investigation by the British Phonographic Industry (BPI) and International Federation for the Phonographic Industry (IFPI). Following their investigation the industry organisations filed a formal complaint with the Strathclyde Police.

Officers obtained a search warrant for Muir's home in 2008 and seized evidence including her computer equipment. They found 30,000 files on her hard drive that were being shared illegally.

District procurator fiscal for Ayr, Mirian Watson said, "Intelligence gathered by BPI and IFPI revealed that Anne Muir was a prolific user of a particular file sharing network based in the UK."

Whilst Muir was facing possible fines and potentially even time in prison, Andrew Crossley, a solicitor, was fined only £1,000 for exposing thousands of individuals' personal information gathered in a scheme to extract payments from alleged music filesharers.

Also, we're not exactly sure how the BPI and IFPI came up with the figure of £54,000 for a bunch of karaoke tracks, but this all happened in the same month that the BPI said that digital music sales were up last year.

While this case was being prosecuted, the BPI announced that retail spending on digital albums had increased by 23 per cent and that total spending broke the £1bn mark in the UK since digital downloading started in 2004. µ

 

Share this:

Comments
They should be careful what they wish for

My little fantasy is that indeed ISP's will indeed filter for the greedy media companies and you won't be able to find music or video anywhere on the internet. Oh, including iTunes, Blockbuster and all the like, because the ISPs can't tell what's pirate and what's legit. Starve all the media companies straight into extinction, says I.

posted by : Carter, 01 June 2011 Complain about this comment
Yawn!!

@Bob

It's hard to take comments like yours seriously, so how would fining her $300m (£180m) make any sense, it's totally disproportionate to any perceived loss. personally I'd rather they fill jails with criminals that are a danger to the public not a danger to a corporations profits. If you want to fill our jails with file sharers then ask the media corporations claiming loss to build them, don't expect the public purse to cover the cost.

I guess you work for one of these corporations, who else after would make such an asinine comment in the first place?

posted by : Common Sense, 31 May 2011 Complain about this comment
I LISTEN TO THE RADIO

COME SLAP THE BRACLETS ON ME, I DONT PAY MY FM BILL.
I CANNA AFFORD THE IPOD, AND BESIDES, THE BATTERY IS ALWAYS DEAD WHEN I GO TO USE IT.

posted by : SHOUTER, 31 May 2011 Complain about this comment
Justice not served

Probation is an insult and a totally inapropiate sentence. She should be fined $10,000 per copy and sentenced to jail like any other criminal.

It won't be long before many countries make piracy a felony crime with mandatory prison time, as it should be. If people are stupid enough to pirate they are stupid enough to go to prison.

posted by : Bob, 31 May 2011 Complain about this comment
What a joke

Turned into a criminal by a civil matter the law is an idiot!

posted by : Brent, 31 May 2011 Complain about this comment
aboutus
Advertisement
Subscribe to INQ newsletters
Advertisement
INQ Poll

Facebook starts selling shares

Will you buy Facebook shares?