THE FOUNDER of technology blog Techcrunch, Michael Arrington has announced that his everyman Tablet PC project, the Crunchpad has been wrestled from his hands and, well, crunched.
Arrington first announced his intention to develop such a machine in July 2008, explaining "I'm tired of waiting - I want a dead simple and dirt cheap touch screen web tablet to surf the web. Nothing fancy like the Dell latitude XT, which costs $2,500. Just a Macbook Air-thin touch screen machine that runs Firefox and possibly Skype on top of a Linux kernel. It doesn't exist today, and as far as we can tell no one is creating one. So let's design it, build a few and then open source the specs so anyone can create them."
By May of this year pictures of the device floated up, showing a 12-inch touch screen pad that skipped the desktop interface to launch web-friendly applications including Firefox, Skype and Google Docs. The Crunchpad squeezed an Intel Atom into its case along with 512MB of RAM, and it excited quite a few people.
Yesterday Arrington blogged that the Crunchpad, though a mere two weeks away from launch, had been shelved because of "greed, jealousy and miscommunication", and some apparent confusion over intellectual property rights. "On November 17, our deadline date for greenlighting the debut three days later, the CEO of our partner (Fusion Garage) on the project, Chandra Rathakrishnan, sent me an email with the subject 'no good news.' Yuck, I thought." And rightly so it appears.
"Bizarrely, we were being notified that we were no longer involved with the project. Our project. Chandra said that based on pressure from his shareholders he had decided to move forward and sell the device directly through Fusion Garage, without our involvement", he added.
There is not much room for negotiation on the table either, according to Arrington. "Renegotiations are always fine. But holding a gun to our head two days before launching and insulting us isn't the way to do that. We've spent the last week and a half trying unsuccessfully to communicate with them. Our calls and emails go unanswered, so we can't even figure out exactly what's happened."
The situation has arisen because neither firm owns the intellectual property rights to the CrunchPad themselves, and while TechCrunch owns the right to the Crunchpad name, they don't own the manufacturing. This means that Fusion Garage, which does, can make the hardware itself without even mentioning the Cruchpad name again. Good news to us because we were getting bored of typing the word Crunch, but a sad day for friendship and the industry.
As Arrington writes, "It's a sad day at Techcrunch HQ. Hitting the publish button on this post, which makes all of this so...final...is a very hard thing to do. I'm enraged, embarrassed, and just...sad. The Crunchpad is now in the Deadpool". µ
This is just plain wrong. If the scarce information is correct, then Fusion are an example of the type of lowlife scum that make life on this planet miserable. I hope that some kind of justice can occur here, even if it looks unlikly to transpire.
Maybe I'm just missing something-
but I can't see how they can get a decent Hardware BOM (Bill of Materials)- in the 200-300 range as promised.
This thing would really need touch screen + Wireless N + WWAN + LED + USB + Battery + MB + CPU + etc + etc
Them things aren't cheap to get them good and that's why an apple tablet is gonna be bank...
... or don't whine when people pull the rug from under you. Really, why would they even call it a "partnership" if they're obviously not bound to work together?
A fool and his "partnership" are soon parted.
Its called glorious failure. Its 100% about how you overcome not what you accomplish. Ditka 101.
If stealth project you would've avoided the litigation hyenas and maybe worked on buttoning up the IP. Next time attend to the IP first - then seek hyena funding
What a total tool for not getting the legalities sorted out first and foremost, what was this "business" relationship based on, a nod and a wink FFS?
Sounds like it's got "fail" written all over it anyway, so he's probably best out of it.
The days were better when your word was good enough. In the good old days, the suits at Fusion would be skinned alive and hung up to dry.
... a publicity stunt. I don't believe there will be any Crunchpad or they had in mind building one in the first place. Snatched or not from their hands two days from lunch as the story claims have you seen it yet?