Jump to content
The Inquirer-Home

UK probation IT system is a complete failure

£41 million wasted, £161 million unaccounted for
Tuesday, 3 November 2009, 13:43

THE GOVERNMENT'S system for tracking criminals through the prison and probation system had "not even a minimum level of competence in [its] planning and execution," according to MPs.

The Commons Public Accounts Committee's verdict on the C-NOMIS system was delivered after £41 million was wasted on delays and cost overruns. There are thought to be millions of pounds more unaccounted for in the project.

Even these MPs, used to ineptitude and ‘blind optimism' in government IT projects, were startled when they investigated.

Chairman of the Public Accounts Committee, Edware Leigh told The Guardian, "This committee has become inured to the dismal procession of government IT failures which have passed before us, but even we were surprised by the extent of the failure of C-NOMIS."

The National Offender Management Service, in charge of prisons and probations, could not even explain what £161 million spent before October 2007 was for when asked by the committee.

The project was started in 2004 and was reckoned to cost £234 million. Two years later, when the final whistle was blown its costs exceeded £700 million.

Now C-NOMIS is no longer used, offenders will be tracked on three separate databases, which won't be up and running until 2011. Which leads us to ask, how will they be tracked in the system?

Conveniently for C-NOMIS, no one can be held accountable because the officials who took the key decisions and were responsible for its monitoring and oversight have all retired or moved on. µ

 

Share this:

Comments
Crazy

We really need to get proper rules and penalties built into corps/companies that tender for Govt contracts. This money has essentially been stolen if it cannot be acounted for.

What is hilarious is there is such a thing as PRINCE2 in the UK. It was setup to help manage IT projects...by the Govt.

Shame that no one ever uses PRINCE2 or enforces its use.

Disgusting.

posted by : jason, 03 November 2009 Complain about this comment
Gov

I work for the government and we do use PRINCE2 and ITIL structures.

But i can see how the money dissapeares or gets wasted. Its just the government, they are forever throwing money away.

posted by : Jim, 03 November 2009 Complain about this comment
@Jim

"I work for the government and we do use PRINCE2 and ITIL structures."

Not very well it appears!

posted by : jason, 03 November 2009 Complain about this comment
prince 2

Prince 2 is just project management for idiots. Enforcing it doesn't stop idiots being idiots but it does cripple people with talent.

It's equivalent would be painting by numbers. Da Vinchi would have loved it.

posted by : epinoa, 05 November 2009 Complain about this comment
OOOPS

Da Vinci even sigh..... How do you spell Michaelan .... whatshisface?

posted by : epinoa, 05 November 2009 Complain about this comment
Prince2?

Prince2 is the latest of the many methodological excuses for not training people. Prince2 won't do your project for you, it'll just make sure that the pathologists can see where it failed. This is the same approach to project management that ISO9001 is to quality. Dealing with the UK civil service on IT projects is a voyage through wish-lists and CV improvement, with the underlying message that since they're paying (Hoot! Gibber!) they know more than you do...

posted by : Chris Mitchell, 05 November 2009 Complain about this comment
Advertisement
Subscribe to the INQ Newsletter
Sign-up for the INQBot weekly newsletter
Click here to sign up Existing user
Advertisement
INQ Poll

Christmas computer sales

Will you be buying a new computer this Christmas?