Jump to content
The Inquirer-Home

Orange Box games bricked by Valve

Buy from the right shop, or else
Friday, 26 October 2007, 09:50

GAMEMAKER Valve is miffing its customers by bricking " Orange Box" games because they have not been bought from an authorised US dealer.

Even though it never told the customer that they had to buy American, Steam is fuming that US customers have been going to foreign shores to buy its Orange Box selection.

It has suddenly regionalised its software so that only games bought in the US can be played on US machines. It is refusing to activate the games online and has switched off those games that were already using the software.

The move has infuriated many bargain hunting gamers who say that they bought the game legitimately online via well known international game stores.

According to Consumerist magazine, Valve did not warn gamers that it was going to do it either. It has also shut down a thread on www.valve.com in a bid to stop its customers talking about it.

While many gamers have managed to get their money back from the vendors from whom they bought their games from, a glich in Valve's software means that even if they buy from a US shop they still cannot run the game.

Apparently Valve's software thinks they have already have a game running and will not allow them to activate a new one.

Consumerist says that customers who try to contact Valve about the problem are ignored. Clearly the company thinks they should have bought American in the first place and are not to be given any help.

It is handy for Valve, it makes money by selling software and refusing to let it work on punter's machines. Of course it will probably get away with it right up until the day of the first class action.

More here. µ

Share this:

Comments
Remember When

I remember when half life 2 came out, and there were horrible "verification" problems and it was taking people untold hours just to get their games unlocked by Steam. People were pirating the entire game, after they had bought it, and playing it before Valve fixed their crap

posted by : Alex, 26 October 2007 Complain about this comment
No Help

This is awful, but now the all powerful valve is moving away from support and is just reaping the rewards.

I am "commenting" on this article because its about valve but I wondered if perhaps you might investigate a problem which no one seems to want to own up to?

Basically up until about 6 weeks ago I could play just about any steam based multiplayer game there was.
Then, all of a sudden everytime I connect I get "warning: connection problem.

So I start this thread on steam forums to get help:

http://forums.steampowered.com/forums/showthread.php?t=598697

To my immediate surprise I found out that I wasn't alone.

Someone in the thread pointed me in the direction of some posible solutions posted in a similar thread:

http://forums.steampowered.com/forums/showthread.php?t=598697

Literally hundreds of people are having the same problem?

It turns out that anyone with a Speedtouch Modem was affected and a smaller number of people with other modems. I'm with BT so i've got their HomeHub which is basically a rebranded speed touch 780.

So I tried everything in the thread and nothing seems to work. I tried a spare router i've got lying around, everything works. It just seems to be the BT home hub.

So it would seem that a steam update caused the initial problem and now there is no way of rolling back. It can't be the firemware for the hub because that wasn't updated recently enough.

Its brilliant to actually have a copy of the Orange box whats not so brilliant is not being able to play TF2.

Valve don't seem to want to know and I spent 1.5 hours on the phone to BT last night and they couldn't suggest anything except ask me to pay them 9.99 to subscribe to their premium support.

*Sigh* I was hoping as kind of a last straw that maybe you could turn some heads at either company to see if they can sort out the problem as no one seems to want to do anything about it.

Thanks in advance

Chris

posted by : Chris, 26 October 2007 Complain about this comment
I dont get it!

Are these companies deliberately trying to convert their customers into pirates? First Bioshock, with its terrible/tight securom protection system which bugged customers but pirates didn't face any problem.

And now this. Again pirates must be enjoying the orange box to the fullest when poor customers are sitting in their home fuming over valve.

Is an man not entitled to the game he buys?
No! Says the man at valve.....

posted by : ORB, 26 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Out of hand

This never ending greed never seem to amaze me, but then again we talking about American based companies right?

posted by : Pierre, 26 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Boycott Valve

Iv'e got all of the steam games ... the kids love em.

They should accept purchases from offshore ... why punish someone who hunts for a bargain anyway?

Sounds like a bad case of greed.

Anyone want to buy my Steam Games?

I'll go back to boxed software ... mongrel thing chews up my download quota anyway.

Add Valve to the following monopolists:

Microsoft
Apple
Intel
Blizzard

Sick Charlie D on em I say ... go on !!

posted by : Reynod, 26 October 2007 Complain about this comment
A simple solution

Just go and download it through torrents, and you will get the game for which you have paid :-)

posted by : Eagle, 26 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Heh...

Valve will only contribute to piracy. The irony of it all...

posted by : Mad Ant, 26 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Grey market

Those are the risks you play when you buy from the grey market. 

People were doing this (and probably still are) for digital cameras and then they expect the US company to service the warranty only to get their britches in a twist when they are refused service. 

Their situation should not be pitied,

- Mr. F1y

posted by : Mr. F1y, 26 October 2007 Complain about this comment
This is why I never have and never will buy Valve software...

I have never liked their online distribution, activation, monitoring, and invasion of privacy system called "Steam."

I have never purchased or played a game made by Valve, and never will as long as they continue to force unwanted software (Steam) and their authority on people who just want to play a stupid computer game.

posted by : bem003us, 26 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Sounds like an attempt at piracy control

The regionalisation is probably an attempt at piracy control.

As far as customer service goes, if they think you're a pirate trying to scam something from their customer service, they ignore you. But obviously for the legit folks, this needs to be fixed.

posted by : The Jedi, 26 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Maybe the next interview...

Maybe the next time all these media outlets decide to go "gaga" over anything that comes out of Gabe Newell's mouth, they should ask him what the *#!k is going on with censorship on pretty much any Valve website. 

As soon as people start complaining in the Steam forums, or in this case on Valve's site, the post gets locked down, deleted, and anybody who mentions the issue again is banned. WTF valve? You used to be cool...

posted by : Clint, 26 October 2007 Complain about this comment
non-working software

quote:
"...It is handy for Valve, it makes money by selling software and refusing to let it work on punter's machines... "

This is pretty much like Microsoft's business model, is not it? XD

posted by : raskolnikov, 26 October 2007 Complain about this comment
link to wrong site

http://www.steampowered.com/v/index.php?area=forums

is Valve's site for Steam and their forums.

Cheers,
John

posted by : John, 26 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Don't blame Valve

This is ridiculous to blame Valve.

Regional vendors/distributors that sell the game keys to overseas purchasers are knowingly violating their agreements with Valve. Thus they are selling illegal copies of the game. Blame the vendor, plain and simple.

If Valve does not shut down these copies, they are in violation of their contracts with the local vendor or distributor, and could easily be held liable in civil court.

If a person bought a boxed copy in person in another country I would expect Valve to honor that license as there are no license violations committed.

posted by : Mike, 26 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Valve is like APPLE....

I would sue if possible.

1) Prior to release, customers were not warned through their web site.

2) A company/corporation has no right to limit execution rights of a product, simply because a customer did not buy it at a store that charges the most for it.

3) Many have legitimately purchased the product, and no warning is on the product itself. This is enough for a class action lawsuit.

This move makes VALVE like APPLE COMPUTERS...in which they LIMIT vendors arranged in a Cartel that has APPLEs proprietary code...and if one doesnt purchase through one of them, the product doesnt work...

This is a far worse than ANY monopoly because Marketting and User Choice is being controlled Internally. The user has NO RIGHTS and the developer actually has the ability to take the money from customers without even giving them anything.

I was going to buy the Orange Box, After reading this article, I will never buy any Valve game in existence.

posted by : Setsunayaki, 26 October 2007 Complain about this comment
You are now under our control

I agree with clint, the censorship of the forums is a way over the top.
And I agree that steam's concept basically is taking control of games YOU bought away from you, and forcing updates that at any time might mess up the game, disable it, add ingame ads, etcetera.
So I also don't buy steam games anymore.

posted by : W.-, 26 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Dev -> distributor

This is what happens when a developer becomes a distrubor. They slowly stop caring about their gamers and making the highest quality product, and start to think primarily of profits. They even rush to market games that are not finished. They then abandon their development. It was promised that dod:S would eventually include vehicle combat (which it doesn't years after it was released). TF2 lacks basic class limit cvars, which have been in pretty much all tf games, as well as all of valves' DoD offerings, and tf2 also lacks the old %h %l %i variables from tfc).


posted by : Steve., 27 October 2007 Complain about this comment
surprised? why?

does that really surprise you?
valve has never been what people hype it to be. I have a 1.5 meg (1600/kbps) connection and when ever i have to d/l css my max d/l is usually around 180/kbps. That reminds me of the battlefield2 controversies over aimbot. Its your fault, you're the reason this companies do what they want. To be fair not all companies can turn evil, ID Software is a good example of how things should work. They're opengl compliant (linux anyone), require no activation, and of course have done way too much for the community by releasing source code. I owe too much to them for releasing ET

posted by : missingxtension, 27 October 2007 Complain about this comment
no tit for tat

Companys want a world where they can do anything they want, anywhere, without restriction, but heaven help you should you, the consumer, want the same.

posted by : Michael, 27 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Re: Mr. F1y

The article says nothing about a "grey" market. This is perfectly legitimate purchasing on the Internet within conditions given by the vendor.
If you're so rabid about buying "in the country", I hope you don't have any stuff made in China (or Taiwan). Kinda contradictory, wouldn't you think ?

I am frankly astounded that a company that sells on the Internet still tries to segment the market in geographically-bound regions.
Sorry Valve, it's the Internet. It's everywhere and for everyone.

Corporate dogs at work.

posted by : Pascal Monett, 28 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Globalisation

I love how companys do everything to explain why globalisation is good while outsourcing jobs to countrys whith lower wages, yet in the same second deny their customer the same right.

posted by : Bjoern, 29 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Letting off Steam!! ahhhhh

These companies seem able to spout globalization when there products are
being made cheap and people in there own countries are being laid off.

But cry foul if you source that product from any where else and you save 
money, these include software, hardware, DVD, Music, Clothes.

One rule for companies and another for us, it might be time to change 
instead of keep buying these products boycott them. The tide will only
change once we hit them where it hurt’s the most.

posted by : Sinjin, 30 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Advertisement
Subscribe to the INQ Newsletter
Sign-up for the INQBot weekly newsletter
Click here to sign up Existing user
Advertisement
INQ Poll

Windows 7 impressions

How is windows 7 working out for you?