Jump to content
The Inquirer-Home

Qualcomm lawyers accused of 'exceptional misconduct'

Withheld documents, allegedly
Wednesday, 9 January 2008, 14:22

SIX ATTORNEYS at Qualcomm have been accused of "exceptional misconduct" by a federal magistrate and referred to the California State Bar for discipline.

During pretrial discovery in recent patent litigation with competitor Broadcom, mobile chipmaker Qualcomm improperly withheld tens of thousands of pages of emails and documents from its adversary and the court, US Magistrate Judge Barbara Major alleged in her 48-page ruling on the case.

At issue in the lawsuit was whether Qualcomm had disclosed its relevant patents to a standards committee.

With teeth clenched, presumably, the judge wrote: "Producing 1.2 million pages of marginally relevant documents while hiding 46,000 critically important ones does not constitute good faith and does not satisfy either the client's or attorney's discovery obligations."

In a statement following Monday's decision, Qualcomm said it regretted "the discovery errors that occurred in this case." It pointed out that it turned over the documents as soon as it found them -- after the trial was over -- and said, "These actions defy any suggestion that Qualcomm engaged in intentional misconduct."

The judge exonerated 13 other attorneys who had represented Qualcomm and ordered the company to review its discovery practices and report back to her later this month.

Qualcomm lost the case and is appealing the court's decision. µ

L'INQ
InformationWeek

Share this:

Comments
So they only found the papers after the trial ?

And that is not supposed to be understood as intentional misconduct ?
Fine, then it can only mean total incompetence. Have their attorney's license removed for life. And set Qualcomm a fine of 10% of their yearly profits for being guilty of hiring incompetent lawyers.
If it doesn't hurt the bottom line, it's not a lesson to be remembered.

posted by : Pascal Monett, 12 January 2008 Complain about this comment
Advertisement
Subscribe to the INQ Newsletter
Sign-up for the INQBot weekly newsletter
Click here to sign up Existing user
Advertisement
INQ Poll

Browsers

Who will win the next round of browser wars?