Jump to content
The Inquirer-Home

Firefox dumps privacy button

Too much like hard work
Monday, 16 June 2008, 10:01

A SECURITY FEATURE which gave punters total privacy has been dumped from the final version of Firefox 3.

Private Browsing would have disabled all caching, cookie downloads, history records, and form data during the session.

If it worked it would have meant you could surf the Web and leave nothing sticky on your computer.

Mozzarella Fountain's big cheese in security Johnathan Nightingale, said that Private Browsing was, in principle, pretty cool. It would mean that what you were about to do would not be logged anywhere.

You hit a button and everything past that point isn't logged. Then you hit the button again and you were visible again.

It would be handy while you were borrowing a computer and didn’t want your mates to see you had been checking out porn, violence, or Apple's product pages.

Nightingale said, however, that the main problem with the button is that it touched a lot of code. It was likely to interact with Web sites and mashups and things like that and was just a crash waiting to happen. µ

L'Inq
News.com

Share this:

Comments
old school

I guess we'll have to stick with manually wiping all our cookies, history etc.

I honestly can't see this being a feature I'd use that much, if at all. It sounds like feature-bloat (and suspect it'd make FF more resource hungry).

posted by : icty, 16 June 2008 Complain about this comment
Sounds like Vista

features being shed to make release dates...

posted by : Mark, 16 June 2008 Complain about this comment
FireBadger - The Pervert's Browser of Choice

I think it more likely that either some US security agency has had a quiet word and told them it doesn't like features that may prevent it looking through confiscated hard drives for evidence, or Mozzarella's PR people are worried that it might become the browser of choice for the world's ne'er-do-wells and this wouldn't be a nice angle for the press to approach future versions...

posted by : Half-a-Mil CEO, 16 June 2008 Complain about this comment
Alternative

www.diskcleaner.nl

posted by : yoyo, 16 June 2008 Complain about this comment
Extensions people

That's what they are there for. Install the add in "Stealther" and this will do exactly what's needed.

posted by : Jason, 16 June 2008 Complain about this comment
Nothing new

Opera has been doing this for years, under a nice menu item called clear privacy data. Cookies, addresses, cache, transfers etc etc are all deleted with two mouse clicks.

Its a simple enough idea, I wonder why they can't code it?

posted by : Raovq, 16 June 2008 Complain about this comment
Sad, but easy to replicate

It's an unfortunate loss, but the feature is surprisingly easy to replicate if you put a little elbow grease into it. These instructions are Windows-specific but can be adapted to any platform.

1.) Start Firefox with the Profile Manager:
firefox -ProfileManager

2.) Create a new profile, call it "secure."
3.) Create a shortcut/link to Firefox that uses this profile:
firefox -no-remote -P secure

4.) Customize the profile to turn off cookies and caching, history, javascript, and whatever else. Also tell it to clear all privacy data on exit, just to be safe. You can use a tool like foxmarks to share select bookmarks.

Firefox keeps this profile data separate, so the "regular" browser will keep your history data but the secure one will not. This gives you options when browsing. Hope this helps.

posted by : Greg, 16 June 2008 Complain about this comment
Firefox wins with add-ons

Keeping multiple profiles around is easier with an extension such as profileswitcher (https://nic-nac-project.de/~kaosmos/profileswitcher-en.html) .

I use this tool on a daily basis.

I haven't used SecureBrowse (https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/5967), but it claims to do the clean-up mentioned above by others.

Also, you can configure your browser to clean our your data when you exit quite easily.

Tools -> Options -> Privacy on Windows
Edit -> Preferences -> Privacy on Linux

posted by : Jason, 16 June 2008 Complain about this comment
They already have this...

There's an extension called Distrust that does pretty much this exact thing...

posted by : Jesus, 16 June 2008 Complain about this comment
Get Safari

Safari has it, "private browsing".

posted by : regulas, 16 June 2008 Complain about this comment
Of course, if you run a real OS

You can just put ~/.mozilla on a ramdisk

posted by : Jim, 17 June 2008 Complain about this comment
Clear Private Data

Like Opera, you can clear cookies, cache, history, etc. very simply in Firefox by using Clear Private Data in the Tools menu. You can even ask for private data to be cleared whenever you exit the browser. Presumably the difference here is that "Private Browsing" would have prevented the information being stored in the first place rather than simply deleting it afterwards.

posted by : Warren, 17 June 2008 Complain about this comment
Or this...

Try Browzar. Does the same. Only its too simple and aint have no plugins and stuff...I think. But does the "wipe all after use" thing too.

posted by : Jhc, 21 June 2008 Complain about this comment
Advertisement
Subscribe to the INQ Newsletter
Sign-up for the INQBot weekly newsletter
Click here to sign up Existing user
Advertisement
INQ Poll

Windows 7 impressions

How is windows 7 working out for you?