Jump to content
The Inquirer-Home

Free Radiohead music pirated

And the point is?
Thursday, 18 October 2007, 09:54

RADIOHEAD'S latest album, which the band allowed to download for how ever much they wanted to pay, is mostly being distributed by pirates.

Big Champagne, a Los-Angeles-based company that tracks illegal downloading on the Internet said that while 1.2 million people legitimately downloaded the album online, 500,000 picked it up from torrent sites.

Eric Garland, Big Champagne's top cork told Forbes that in a few weeks the numbers of pirated copies will be even greater than the legitimate sales. It has him scratching his head wondering why people would bother pirating something they could get legitimately.

Garland thinks that piracy is more habit than price. He thinks that since people do not know about Radiohead's site they will just go to their favourite Bittorrent site. You also have to register for the album which some buyers do not like.

However as far as the band is concerned, Radiohead seems to have been coins in on the plan. It has cut out record companies and keeps all the money from album sales, touring and merchandise.

It has also had more copies sold. Radiohead's previous album sold only 300,000 copies in the first week. µ

Share this:

Comments
Radiohead

This is exactly it. Even though it may be available from their site it is much easier and consistent just to grab a torrent. Also you don't have to bother going through the registration hassle on their badly designed website.
Even though I think what Radiohead have done is amazing, the service people want always shine through; I'll use Google search instead of Live search, Linux instead of Windows, and torrents when it comes to movies and films.

posted by : Scott Philips, 18 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Not odd at all

Kind of the same idea how Microsoft got so wide spread. 

Maybe people just want to try before they buy. Too bad Vista was not like that.

Think of it this way. I have probably never personally went out and purchased a album if I had not heard it somewhere first. Kind of like taking a car for a test drive. Nothing odd about that. 

If People despise the RIAA they will make sure they will actually go out and buy this album.

Vote with your wallet. Now is your chance.

posted by : NWO, 18 October 2007 Complain about this comment
The Onion?

The title of the article reminds me of the one-liners The Onion used to do. All in all I think it's good that Radiohead is making a fair but of money out of the deal and hopefully their idea will spread throughout the industry.

posted by : William Ely, 18 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Pirating free music - no wai!

Why torrent when its 'free'?

Maybe it is force of habit

Maybe it's the legal site being slooooowwww.

Maybe its 45p to creditcard monopolies people really don't want to pay.

Or just maybe people want to hear the music first to decide what it is worth.

posted by : ranting raver, 18 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Convenience/Habit

I think a lot of it is a combination of convenience and habit as I have also seen many freely available demos on torrent sites.

posted by : Braindeed, 18 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Re:Not odd at all

Err, but you could, there was a 30 or 60 day free trial available to all, can't remember the exact period.

posted by : Braindeed, 18 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Distribution Model

It just goes to show that the distribution model of the main stream "Scene" is more effective than the corporate (iTunes, website downloads, etc) distribution models.

Main stream "scene" being a direct reference to the "Pirate Scene" this mainstream 'torrent' one much less hard core, however much more effective than the Pirate Scene in moving bits around.

Perhaps the suits should listen.

posted by : Giz Manning, 18 October 2007 Complain about this comment
tried dl, but too slow

I don't know bout the rest, but I tried to get it off of Rhead's site, but it was excruciatingly slow. It took 35 minutes to grab it off TPB with a couple hundred peers.

Still, cheers to Rhead for abandoning the abusive recording industry. If anything, I'd buy their album over anyone else's just for the fact that I know ALL the money goes straight to them.

posted by : anlah, 18 October 2007 Complain about this comment
scanner darkly?

anyone notice how this album sounded like it was the unused material left over from A Scanner Darkly'?

I'm not complaining, the new album is alright. Their best new material to date belongs to the movie sndtk though.

posted by : scanner, 18 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Some reasons why

The official site is not exactly easy to find, it's a bit hard to navigate (though not as confusing as Radiohead's main site) and, the last time I tried, so slow that I gave up. I do plan to buy the album "officially" (Radiohead are one of the few bands making good, original music these days), and I'll probably pay around 15 euros for it, but meanwhile I'm listening to a copy downloaded from a P2P network simply due to the difficulty in using the official site.

P.S. - The official album is in MP3 160 kb/s format. Would it be too much to ask for an uncompressed, or at least 320 kb/s version...?

P.P.S. - I wonder who will be the first band to distribute their music through Valve's Steam.

posted by : Temporary Pirate, 18 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Why not pay for the torrent download?

Radiohead is missing a trick here. Why do they go to all the trouble of providing a download site? Radiohead should just add a button to allow people to pay for a download, whatever the source. I'm sure they don't care how you get a copy, and they can save a bit of money on server charges if customers use P2P to download the music.

I think all bands should add a button to their website to allow people to "tip" the band in return for a download, from bit torrent or anywhere else. The RIAA won't like it, but I'd rather download and pay the band directly and avoid paying all the middlemen involved in manufacturing, shipping and selling a CD.

Unfortunately, I'm not interested in compressed music, so I won't be downloading this particular album. But if a lossless version shows up in a torrent somewhere, I'd love to be able to download that and pay the band for it.

posted by : jimsum, 18 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Did Both.

I went throught the site and got my download address/code but After two failed attempts my address stopped working so I just scooped up the torrent instead. Later, I requested a new address and downloaded it from the proper site. Considering how poor things were working on the morning of release I doubt i was the only one. 


posted by : billy!, 18 October 2007 Complain about this comment
It's a start

It's a start - but registering on web forms can't compete with the flexibility of torrents today. With torrent managers supporting RSS feeds, there's not even a page you have to open anymore to start downloading.

posted by : Axion, 18 October 2007 Complain about this comment
See, what they should have done...

...was made a torrent themselves. Host the .torrent on the official site, block tracker access to any IP that hasn't downloaded the .torrent from the official site to keep the numbers in check, and save the people who didn't want to pay anyway the wait, as well as speeding the download up for anyone who fancied paying. 

Everyone wins. 

As for me, I tried downloading it legitimately from the site, but my patience only goes so far.

posted by : Dave, 18 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Why pirate this?

I bought it for 5£ of their site. took med all of 30 sec to type in my info. 15 sec to verify my creditcard and all of 1-2 min to download the album at around 2 Mbyte/sek(exact speed I can't recall). 

I fail to see the difficult part of getting your music Legal in this case.


posted by : Kerberos, 18 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Why don't they distribute it as a torrent, then they don't pay for the bandwidth?

Radiohead should put it out as a torrent, then they don't have to pay the bandwidth.

Didn't they have an album called "Ok Computer"? Maybe they are saying "Ok" to the computer users.

posted by : Bomboom, 19 October 2007 Complain about this comment
Advertisement
Subscribe to the INQ Newsletter
Sign-up for the INQBot weekly newsletter
Click here to sign up Existing user
Advertisement
INQ Poll

Christmas computer sales

Will you be buying a new computer this Christmas?