The Inquirer-Home
Comments
@Stormy

Why do you think the US has had "control" over such technologies? Could it be because they were invented or at least commercialized in the US? These kinds of things take time, research, and money--investments that people want to earn returns on.

But that's not the real issue here.

It's not "why is the US in control over such technologies?"--but rather "why have others *failed* to take control of them?" Surely, Amercians aren't any "smarter" than people in other places--and surely, industrialized nations like those in Europe should be well equipped with universities, a well educated populace, and resources?

I think it comes down to this sense of "entitlement." The quote: "Like the electricity, fuels, medicines, etc. - [the Internet] is a resource no country should be denied of, as it could influence its economy badly" reflects this. It's the idea that what others create should be shared, no matter how little your contribution (if any). People call them "rights."

But that's not how the world works. Where are the "rights" to electricity, fuel, medicine, etc. for people in Africa? It's not being paid for by Europe that's for sure. Nobody likes to subsidize *other* countries. So they're "rights" only for "citizens"--i.e. the people who are paying for it.

Likewise, the US and others don't subsidize technologies for other countries. The US doesn't manufacture computer chips to help Chinese or European citizens computer--not for free anyway.

Does this really hurt the economies of countries? Sure, those who expected a free ride. But for others, it means they create their own innovations and technologies. When Microsoft stopped updating IE for Apple's OSX the response was a home-grown solution: Safari. Likewise, keeping the US's GPS network controlled by the US is spawning other initiatives, like Europe's Galileo network.

The US will continue to control technologies until other competitors enter the fray. If you don't like it, do something, or accept your dependence.

posted by : BB, 02 October 2009 Complain about this comment
This just has to be another bot

Are we entirely sure that DRASHEK isn't running another script? I know the lunatic left is universally stupid, regardless of country of origin, but some of these guys shouldn't be able to figure out how to use keyboards.

posted by : Chris, 02 October 2009 Complain about this comment
A good, safe, and essential move

As the US moves ever closer to a corporate controlled fascist state, this excellent move will insure that a future GW Bush ( and he will arrive; AmeriKKKans are very stupid, cowardy, provincial, and an amazingly ignorant people ) will be unable to quash International opinion, stifle dissent, or flood propaganda about some threat (WMD) to the world.

Hopefully, the next time the AmeriKKKans try to drag the world into Armageddon, they can be effectively isolated to their own sad Internet shores. At least their vile vomit can me shut down.

Good move ICCAN! Long live the INTERNATIONAL net!

Oh.... I am an American, fighting to restore democracy, peace, and justice to a lost and dying imperialist power. We are not ALL idiots over here. Just most!

--
"Fascism should more properly be called corporatism because it is the merger of state and corporate power." -- Benito Mussolini

posted by : Tamara Bunke, 01 October 2009 Complain about this comment
@Stitch

"I've heard that Americans teach their children that they won the second world war - that made me laugh :)
Maybe they should tell their children how they cowardly waited up till 1944 to grab the share of the European pie"

Psst: the US & UK invaded Europe in September of 1943 (Italy). Your facts are wrong. Actually, much of what you said shows the same bias.

Its probably time that the USA stepped away from the web as its become bigger than any one country. I don't have too much hope that the international community can do a better job (really, ICANN did an OK job) but hopefully it won't schtuff it up too much. There's only one internet.

posted by : Scottmo, 01 October 2009 Complain about this comment
Let watch and see the sparks fly

Can't wait to see how this goes, mostly with every Muslim country dictatorships or mulla starts to voice their disapproval what ever gets them crazy ever few minutes.

I can see how it was an issue, but since I did not see it been something that was broken I see nothing new here and only possible complaints from ever dick and harry government.

Let me get my popcorn and watch the craziness ensue.

posted by : Alexander, 01 October 2009 Complain about this comment
Pat(i)en/t/(ce)

@BB as much as I don't like his attitude, Stitch has some valid points - in the last 20 years USA acquired too much control over the technologies (Software/Hardware and Internet).

Considering the absurd patent system, pro-monopolistic politics/lobbyism, and recent attitude against those-who-dare-not-to-agree commissions - the rest of the world is understandably concerned.

Thou your military invented it, Internet is not something that only concerns your country's economy anymore. Like the electricity, fuels, medicines, etc. - this is a resource no country should be denied of, as it could influence its economy badly. Yet you still want to be able to control it, as if your politicians are flawless and impartial. Sorry, but we've all seen how their judgment ended up for the Iraq, hence the World does not trust them anymore...

P.S. Although ICANN is an "independent" US corporation it still complies with all of your government's laws and decrees.

posted by : Stormy, 01 October 2009 Complain about this comment
@Stitch

Ah yes, there's one on every forum: the guy who takes any opportunity, no matter how out of context or ridiculous, to air the unrelated dirty laundry of America. Do us a favor and just stay on the BBC "Have Your Say" section with the rest of your kind, we don't need even more pollution with Drashek around.

posted by : BB, 01 October 2009 Complain about this comment
Yeahhh, away from the fascist state

All I can say it is a relief!!!

America is like "stalin" in disguise. Give it a finger and it will bite the whole hand off.

What Americans should stop doing is consuming things they can not afford (fat bastards)

And maybe, just maybe they should stop delivering their "freedom" all over the world, otherwise somebody might just get angry one day ;)

It's funny how a country without history trying to teach the rest of the world how to live. 300 years ish - wow !!!
You're like monkeys on the trees with a fat wallet to people of China, Russia and Europe too.

I've heard that Americans teach their children that they won the second world war - that made me laugh :)
Maybe they should tell their children how they cowardly waited up till 1944 to grab the share of the European pie

Oh, yes, good move for the internet :)

Have a good day.

posted by : Stitch, 01 October 2009 Complain about this comment
This will have some ramifications...

First person to register GÓÓgle.com wins!

posted by : Dizzious, 30 September 2009 Complain about this comment
What good can come from this?

Was my country somehow unjust in how it carried out its affairs? Was anyone denied access? Was anything broken?

With the rest of the world moving to some type of censorship, this seems like a really bad move.

I pity the country that gets internet sanctioned first.

posted by : Integr8d, 30 September 2009 Complain about this comment

US loosens its grip on the Internet

aboutus
Advertisement
Subscribe to INQ newsletters
Advertisement
INQ Poll

Authorities in several countries raided Megaupload recently, shut down all of its services, seized hundreds of servers and arrested several of its executives on criminal charges.

Do you think the move was justified?