" [The US] risks being left behind the rest of the world in this too, as it already is in other areas, like affordable health care and broadband adoption."

What a pathetic statement! Only a moron would argue that something like an island with three people, 100% of its population, with broadband connection and a whole population having to shell out half of their income to self-serving states as benchmarks for anything.

Save Me Save Me,someone is to loud sitting next to me. What next you’re going to outlaw sleeping on planes so you don’t have the risk of hearing someone snore. A large number of people on planes are business people with blackberries and iphone that could continue to work while in flight. If you’re so darn sensitive buy some earplugs and stop stifling progress.

... to your loved ones.

The law, and on-plane jamming, will have dis-allowed it.

Won't that please either god or satan...

: )

I wonder which of the two it would please?

I fail to see how these people will be any different in what they say or do without phone use? They're just as liable to talk about the same stupid rantings with the people seated with them. The people are the problem, not the technology. If being annoying was outlawed everyone would be in jail.

Does it really fit within role of government to legislate phone usage? Whats next, a ban on sneezing because it'd be nice if people didn't sneeze anymore. Before you know it they'll try to take our guns. We'll be just like the UK where the pansies aren't afforded the right to defend themselves. Actually they aren't afforded many other rights for that matter. 
Get a real bill of rights people!

Representative Peter DeFazio is not from Portland, rather from southern Oregon that tends to be republican.

Good! I'll vote for him if he wants to pass such a law. I, for one, don't want to be sitting a mere half a foot from someone yammering on a cell phone. It's bad enough there are so many babies on these damn flights. They should ban them from theatres as well, or at least jam them.

Can't legislate courtesy? Maybe not, but you can certainly destroy the means to cause discourtesy, and on flights, that should be quite easy.

Sorry, I'm gonna have to side with the lawmakers here. I'm not going to sit for hours next to an idiot babbling on the phone, and I don't think anybody else would, either. If this means we are "left behind" by the "rest of the world" (I lol'd after reading that part.) then I couldn't care less.

Mission creep is endemic to bureaucratic restrictions. So why not use it as a force for *good*. Anyone pulling out a mobile, the Sky Marshals blow their head off. And all the other passengers applaud.

This bloke started yammering on his cell like there is no tomorrow inside a silent train car. What surprised me is how he lashed back at people that politely asked him to STFU, after giving him a few minutes of lenience.




ffs why anybody needs to pollute aircraft cabins with their shiny toys is beyond me, the 'dear john' guy could have tipped over the 'edge' and decided to 'end it all' and taken the rest of the punters with him !!! O_o

whats so furkin important at 35,000 feet that cant wait a couple of hours, ffs even if it is important, wtf ya gonna do about it whilst your at said 35,000 feet, these droids (you know who you are) wanna take time out, get a life and enjoy the view/ride ffs !!!!!

ITS A PHONE, NOT A FURKIN LIFE SUPPORT SYSTEM !!!!!!

Not having them talking in my ear on a long flight will save them from being beaten to death with their own phone.

I think for once I will have to agree with those bozo's we vote for.... cell users in general are a loud, obnoxious lot... sitting next to some moron going on and on... my actions would probably put me on a terrorist/no fly watch muy pronto

As the hive mind forms, it is important that refuseniks be assimilated with conditioning meted out in close quarters by the already Borg. Silence and its potential to engender thought are treason.

"Should the US make its ban on inflight cellphone use permanent, it risks being left behind the rest of the world in this too, as it already is in other areas, like affordable health care and broadband adoption. "

Get real... Nothing We like better than listening to someone having the meaningless drivel conversations, that people have when there really is nothing to say, but they're bored. And you want to be strapped in next to one of these idiots for a cross country flight? There will be death... and the other passengers will cheer.

If this means that we have less respect in eyes of the "rest of the world" Who really cares? 

As for those who feel obliged to inform everyone around them of their personal lives, don't be offended when someone gives you advice on your rash or other unmentionable problems.

Should ban them on all bus and coaches too.

Trains have quiet areas. So should Buses.


Well, we have now found one area in which US is more sensible than the EU.

Just like stop signs don't stop cars, they can pass all the legislation they want, people won't ever stop talking on their cel phones. Laws against talking on cel phones while driving haven't stopped that, either. 

You'd think the airline industry would just be jamming cel phone signals and back a ban on passenger cel phone use, anyway. Otherwise noone would need to use the overpriced in-cabin phone anymore.