I know the courts are looking more and more favorably towards the defendants of these suits, but I really wonder if she can successfully appeal. Offering oneself up for prostitution, or attempting to sell illegal goods is usually enough to be found guilty (criminal intent). As for downloaders, requiring proof that any files were downloaded seems very reasonable. If she does win, it will undoubtedly damage the legal campaign, which as it is, is already being toned down.

Her lawyer was a complete tool. The newspaper indicates her lawyer was commenting on how great the Judge was... (The judge that ruled against their case.) Nice... I could have represented myself better then him.

So, if I own a shotgun and pistol store, and I sell a kill pistol to someone legally, and they go and murder someone....Am I liable for "making it available?"

I love America. The only country where no evidence is needed to convict someone of a crime!

The land of the free? Who ever told you that is your enemy!
(Rage Against the Machine)