The Inquirer-Home
Comments
"iPhone" is a spelling mistake

It's true, check the dictionary.
So is "sony".
So is "mochasoft".
So is "kookamunga".

posted by : Grunchy, 23 September 2008 Complain about this comment
Mochasoft reaction

To finish this article and add missing things, Mochasoft has properly pulled its GPL violating apps from the app store and acknowledged the fact in a proper manner. Please see the follow-ups of the discussion in the legal mailing list on www.gpl-violation.org

Additionally there seems to be another project based on rdesktop as well as many other projects based on other GPL licensed software (e.g. samba,...)

Best regards,
Peter

posted by : Peter Honeder, 23 September 2008 Complain about this comment
already pulled from appstore (?)

as of 11:50am est on Monday, the rdp is no longer avail for download from the appstore (though it is still listed in the directory of the appstore).

did mocha implicitly admit defeat?

or did apple force the withdrawl?

[Er, the INQ outed it, of course! Mod.]

posted by : zahadum, 22 September 2008 Complain about this comment
GPL

Surely you mean Guh-noo Public License.

posted by : someguy, 22 September 2008 Complain about this comment
Clear case of violation

Assuming the symbols actually do belong to rdesktop software, Mochasoft is in clear violation of the GPL. 

Surprising that Mochasoft left the symbol names as they were. Maybe they're not even aware that rdesktop's symbols would remain in their object code. Maybe they never heard of a binary API?

The reasoning of Mochasoft is futile. What if people reasoned like this: "Emacs was developed on a PDP and my HTC Touch Diamond has a different input and screen than a PDP (8?) so porting the Emacs code to an HTC Touch Diamond doesn't violate the GPL? Right?" 

WRONG.

posted by : Vijay, 22 September 2008 Complain about this comment
you still

You still don't know how to spell iPhone and iPod after all these years.

posted by : Azazello, 22 September 2008 Complain about this comment
Fire to frying pan.

Of course, releasing the source code will be a direct violation of Apple's T&C's (that famous NDA) , so they're basically screwed. Damned if they do (release the code) damned if they don't.

posted by : Anon, 22 September 2008 Complain about this comment
Don't Mess With The GPL

If you check the long list of settled cases at gpl-violations.org, you'll see that very few of them actually get as far as court. The companies almost inevitably see the light, once their lawyers realize that this is a real licence with some legal teeth behind it.

posted by : Lawrence D'Oliveiro, 22 September 2008 Complain about this comment

Mochasoft Iphone, Ipod app. violates GPL

aboutus
Advertisement
Subscribe to INQ newsletters
Advertisement
INQ Poll

Authorities in several countries raided Megaupload recently, shut down all of its services, seized hundreds of servers and arrested several of its executives on criminal charges.

Do you think the move was justified?