Microsoft takes back the music
Rant Choose piracy
MICROSOFT JUST SCREWED its music customers. In doing so, it proved what we have said all along, if you buy DRM'd anything, you are an idiot, Piracy is the Better Choice(R)(TM)(C).
The firm has arbitrarily decided that all the music you bought from it is now worthless because it can't be bothered to live up to its end of the bargain. It goes something like this, MS came up with a DRM infection and attached it to its music downloads. When the Zune came out, it decided it wanted a bigger piece of the pie, so it cut out all its partners.
The new toy, the Zune has a completely different DRM infection making any of the things you bought from Microsoft saddled by the old way incompatible with the new way. All the partners that made devices compatible with the old way, and all of the people who bought infected music, well, MS has your money, so you're dumped.
This was about a year and a half ago. Today, MS is saying that come August 31, a week or four shy of the two-year anniversary of the night of long knives, you will not be able to re-authorise your music. That means that the music is yours to keep. On one PC. As long as it doesn't crash. Or you don't update your OS. Or something doesn't just decide to stop the music playing. If you do any of these things, you just lost your music permanently.
Basically, MS is stealing from you. It has your money, but you can't have access the services you bought any more. So they are stopping, and legally, you are screwed. Microsoft has got your money though.
We have been saying for years that ANY sort of DRM is unacceptable, and this goes to show you exactly what we mean. Anyone who bought music from MS just got screwed, period, without recourse. It also proves what we have said for almost the same amount of time, Piracy is the Better Choice (R)(TM)(C).
MS has once again proven that if you steal the music, legality aside, you get a better product. Legally purchased music is demonstrably worse than pirated music. There has never been a case that I am aware of of a pirated copy deciding not to play any more because someone in Redmond decided it was inconvenient. You just get a better product, cheaper too, but also illegal.
MS laughing at customers is only part of the problem though. Think about this. You know about the activation in XP and office, along with the malware called MS Genuine Advantage? You know, the stuff that you have to call in or it cripples your paid for and legal software in the name of catching pirates.
It is laughably easy to get around, even in Vista, but it makes things very hard or impossible for people like me who want to stay legal. Basically if you pay, you are hurt, if you pirate, you avoid the hassle, making Piracy the Better Choice (R)(TM)(C) once again.
Back to the point, what do you think will happen to those XP installs once MS decides they are inconvenient? I'll bet you didn't think about that one, that your OS can go away if MS wants it to, remotely, and without you being able to do anything about it. Read the fine print and weep.
It used to be the case that once activated, you were fine, but the WGA malware changed that, and SP3 looks to change it more. With the Broken OS, the malware and spyware is built in, and clings tenaciously to your rights like a blood sucking tick. If you don't phone home every 90 or so days, it helpfully turns off for you. Like Beijing during the Olympics, you may have bought a condo with a beautiful vista, but as soon as the eyes of the world are off and money intervenes, the smog comes back and your vista is gone.
MS has demonstrated that your rights and purchases are secondary to its cash flow. Now the firm has unashamedly screwed everyone, partners and customers, who touched their DRM infected music schemes. And the people just bent over and smiled. They inflicted spyware on paying XP customers, and are only a watchful eye away from shutting you down.
With the Broken OS, they upped the ante on the backs of the legit customers. More than anything else, that is a reason to avoid it like the plague. If you buy anything with a DRM infection, you are a fool. If you buy any MS product with a DRM infection, you are a fool that has been warned many times.
For a good alternative, Ubuntu 8.04 comes out today, get a copy for 100% less than the broken OS here. Failing that, Piracy is the Better Choice (R)(TM)(C). µ

Comments
Your forgot...
You may as well mention our friend Sevey Jobby... lets not give M$ all the flack... Apple could just as easily kill all your iTunes music and as you know, they actually have quite a lot of dumb customers to actually piss off! heheIt doesn't end there.
They use the same type of rubbish on the xbox360 as well. If you buy(rent more like it) software form XBLive Market Place and your console dies and you buy a new machine, you can only use your(their) content if you are connected to XBLive. It really hits home when the service goes down.DRM is the DEVIL
Did not forget...
Your forgot...You may as well mention our friend Sevey Jobby... lets not give M$ all the flack... Apple could just as easily kill all your iTunes music and as you know, they actually have quite a lot of dumb customers to actually piss off!
NO, HE SAID IF YOU BUY DRMed ANYTHING. THAT INCLUDES I-TUNES. OF COURSE, YOU CAN USE STANDARD MP3s IN YOUR IPOD IF YOU MUST USE AN IPOD.
Think DRM...
...think of a "Tune" then "bite" it...how to be genuine in this day and age.
I think the new way of doing things right has to be that you only buy an album if you find yourself listening to it alot onyour mp3 player.I once ripped my whole music collection from genuine cd's only to find when i changed the pc that drm kicked in and wouldn't let me open them again. Never figured out why.
So i downloaded them and used them to my hearts content. But whilst i was searching the appropriate places, i get all the other stuff i couldn't afford shoved in my face.
Thank you very much! but to be a better person, of the music that i did listen to, i did go out and actually buy their albums, only for the disc to sit on a cd player (yes i have one).
Sad that they just don't get it do they!
You will never stop pirating, so cut your costs, and make genuine music viable again FFS!!!!!!
Well said Charlie & infectedbyDRM
This is a perfect example of why DRM is totally unacceptable. I worry about what I'll do in 10 years time if I want to play Pac-Man CE or Ikaruga on my 360. If Live is no longer running (or compatible with 360s) how will I play my games?Even more worrying is what will happen next gen when supposedly all games will move to digital downloads and everything is infected with DRM requiring a permanent internet connection.
At least with iTunes you've got DVD Jon to remove the DRM infection.
Aahh but . . .
Your forgot...You may as well mention our friend Sevey Jobby... lets not give M$ all the flack... Apple could just as easily kill all your iTunes music and as you know, they actually have quite a lot of dumb customers to actually piss off!
NO, HE SAID IF YOU BUY DRMed ANYTHING. THAT INCLUDES I-TUNES. OF COURSE, YOU CAN USE STANDARD MP3s IN YOUR IPOD IF YOU MUST USE AN IPOD.
But also don't forget that if you use an Ipod for mp3's you can't use it with more than one computer and you cant copy your own music off the thing.
Steam as DRM?
I guess Valve's Steam is similar. It helps in some ways, at least for playing older HL1 games online, but it's pretty much like DRM. Some of the stuff you get are always "unnavailable for offline use", and you need to log in at least once to even get into offline mode. Luckily, it's all to a much lesser extent, with some plusses.Nevertheless, I have to agree: DRM is the Devil's Reach in our Machines! :\
Doesn't affect me
Got a Cowon player. Plays all formats including Ogg and Flash. Appears as a hard drive in Windows explorer. If I want to buy music I order a CD.Can't get all worked up about it.
MSN Music only (for now)
It almost sounds like MS is saying it will shut down all of Plays for sure, it's just MSN Music. This is the statement from MS."As of August 31, 2008, we will no longer be able to support the retrieval of license keys for the songs you purchased from MSN Music or the authorization of additional computers. You will need to obtain a license key for each of your songs downloaded from MSN Music on any new computer, and you must do so before August 31, 2008. If you attempt to transfer your songs to additional computers after August 31, 2008, those songs will not successfully play."
If MS can't be bothered to keep a couple of servers running I don't think anyone else will be any better.
United
There are very few things everybody in the IT industry agrees on, and that it DRM.I think most people agree that DRM, in principle is a good idea. However the problem is that no DRM provider has been able to make it work.
People just wait fair use, to be able to backup their songs and copy them to a new device when the old one dies, share some songs with friends.
All DRM needs to do is to prevent the material from being shared on mass. I don't mean shutting down P2P, but if DRM worked as it was supposed to, the vast majority wouldn't need to get their music illegally. Sure some people always want something for nothing - but for most of us we just want a fair deal and consistency.
Sad but true
the article is so true that it's sad.What happened to a neutral press?
If I am not mistaken the press should always, (_always_) be neutral. The author should never give out his own opinion. I do not disagre with the author, but he should not say that unless it is a test/revew or something. Maybe that's just in Norway though where we have these press principles.Ubuntu release date
...is actually the 27th April, not today :-}Other than that, i've got the release candidate installed and it works a treat here !
Call me old fashioned
This stuff is why I still think it is best to buy music and software the old fashioned way. Go down and buy it at your local store on a CD/DVD then you have it always so to say.A friend at work has just had is pissbox 360 give up the ghost like so many others. Go with PS3 no monthly fees. I will stay with PC gaming because I am an old fart but at least I am not being taken to the cleaners by MS.
Apple ARE trying to do away with DRM
and they make it not very hard to scrape off (burn to CD and re-rip at the simplest). Un-DRM'd AAC (MPEG4 audio for those who think that Apple invented their own format) is better quality than MP3 and is supported by most modern MP3 players, so iTunes+ downloads aren't even bound to iPods.Anarchy will fix everything
Once upon a time I couldn’t play EU DVDs on official SONYA in US, and then I bought in Superstore Dayingwood DVD player and all my EU DVD collection is just fine…. Thanks to Asian anarchist who just don’t care about any kind of limiting us infection!If rich (like M$) stealing from poor and able to pay to (rich) lawyers that is ok. If poor copying files from rich they start to sue grandmas to send “message”.
Not just annoying
While that steaming pile DRM is annoying, at least it can't hurt you, right? Wrong!!http://www.microsoft.com/technet/security/bulletin/MS07-067.mspx
Alas!...
Poor ABBA. I knew (Anni-Frid, Benny, Bjorn, Agnetha) well.To AB or not to BA: that is the question, or some such dervish!
Oh, 'sorry: I thought it obligatory to comment, as well. DRMit!-)
Music Library
All my LPs (records) still work just fine. Don't seem to cause any ploblems at all.I admit, carrying them in my pocket requires a very large pocket.
Talking to the converted
I gave up buying CD's and DVD's after they started deliberately corrupting them so I couldn't watch them on my computer.You also forgot to mention that pirate DVD's don't subject you to 30 minutes of unavoidable advertising garbage before the main feature, another great feature of piracy!
"please
don't stop the music"Couldn't agree more. Piracy. The better choice.
DRM punishes the innocent
I have had experiences where I have actually purchased music online only to be locked out of my purchased music over time (change of PC, OS etc). I have pretty much downloaded equivalent torrent versions of all my purchases just to get past the DRM infection.If I want to enjoy the convenience of downloaded music guess where I go straight to now?
Defeats the purpose don't you think?
ALWAYS REMEMBER...
Amazon MP3 is the answer, no strings attached.DRM is indeed the DEVIL
DRM is Good?
> I think most people agree that DRM, in principle is a good idea. -- MarkHuh? Why would "most people" agree? When I buy something, I want to use it any way I wish, and I don't think I'm alone. DRM prevents this, so is inherently anti-customer.
And Norway guy, you think the press can be neutral? If so, that's a little naive.
Burn your music to CD now
AFAIK the solution is quite simple, just burn the files to CD *now*. Then they're safe for as long as the CD will last at least.As for the guy who thinks Steve Jobs is better... In a word: No. The only reason iTunes started selling DRM-free music was because it looked like the others who were already DRM-free would eat their lunch. It was a purely commercial decision. May I remind you that iTunes DRM pre-dates MS Plays-for-Sure by some three years?
Apple is the monopoly in this market anyway.
Easily fixed...
The solutions are simple to the following problems.(1) RIAA and other Recording Industries around the world got your goat?
=> Don't listen to their music. Don't buy it, don't download it. Turn off the radio.
Classical and other music not manufactured by the industry is better for your brain. Give it a shot sometime. Hell, be creative and mix your own! Share it with the world under Creative Commons License....Why not learn to play an instrument? (Anything can be learnt if you put your heart into it).
If you're in your car, why not listen and learn with self help tapes? Sounds corny, but the amount of time you may spend can be used to learn a new language or some new skill.
(2) MPAA and etc around the world annoying you?
=> Don't watch their movies. Don't buy it, don't download it.
Read good books instead. (This is apparently a lost art to many).
A paper-based book (not E-Book!) has a once off fee, and comes with no subscription services. You can take it anywhere with you, it isn't tied to any particular platform. It doesn't require batteries.
And best of all, it has NO DRM. Even better, it has a resale value!
(3) Microsoft frustrating you?
=> Dump them. You paid for a system, it should be yours to do as you please. Its none of their business what you do with your system, as long as you don't use it to hurt others.
They shouldn't have any right to conduct electronic strip searches and rectum exams on a regular basis. ("Genuine Advantage").
I know its hard to leave Windows. You have to research and prepare for it. You also have to make the effort to break old habits you've picked up! (I've learnt this from experience!)
In fact, you really are better off using something else! (DRM isn't the only reason).
The formula is simple: if a corporation is annoying you or have not provided a service that you paid for, don't use them again. There's no need to petition, protest, etc.
You can walk away. Vote with your wallets. It doesn't matter how much bling they show. They cannot do anything if you refuse to accept what they have to offer.
Remember: They need your money, and they'll do anything and everything to get you to pay. You have the power until you hand it over. The choice is all yours. Be responsible about the choices you make.
There is no business if there are no customers. Walk away, and they're screwed. Hurt them where it counts.
No. Don't pirate. (despite what Charlie says). Do NOT give them anymore excuses to change to more harsher laws! Haven't we had enough DMCA-related nonsense?
They can influence many minds, but they can't influence yours if you don't let them. That's what counts.
RE: What happened to a neutral press?
You may or may not have noted that the title of the article includes the word 'rant'. Now, to my mind, an article titled as a 'rant' is never going to be a neutral news article and will instead be an opinion piece. What, exactly, were you expecting?Opinion pieces are very valid in the world of journalism and are to be found on the pages of just about every publication out there. Get over it.
DRM has to go..
"All my LPs (records) still work just fine. Don't seem to cause any ploblems at all. "I was actually looking online for a Laser LP player.. I seemed to find only 1 brand and they where priced at $10,000-15,000 !!!
If there had been a Laser LP player for maybe $300-400 i would have thought of purchasing one for my 10 or so LP's.. I wonder why this tech has not became mainstream.
Its getting hard to buy CD's offline.. not many places left to find them in a small town :(
otherwhise I agree that drm has to go.. im ripping my cd collection to flac.. just need to find a good PMP with flac..
READ THIS (Sent to Charlie)
The one thing no commenter said, so please consider writing a new article around this idea...You (DRM'd music buyer) have paid for the rights to said music. As long as you retain proof of your purchase, you retain rights to download it from ANY source.
Just as you are free to download any track from any CD you own, you are also free to download any song you have already paid legal rights to.
Where in the EULA of MS music does it say that MS is not responsible to provide proof-of-purchase? The person who paid has rights, period. MS may have laywers up the ass but they have no say in this. If you paid, you own. If you own, it is not piracy.
Long and short: If staying legal is your goal, buy your music from the cheapest legal provider and from then on you are invincible in court. Talk to a lawyer, they will agree (after the requisite claim that this is untested ground).
DRM need not be evil, we just need to take it back.
Yes
Download freeware audio recording app - install+run app - hit Rec - play DRM-music - hit Stop - delete DRM-music - repeat until food on table - eatSure, ubuntu.
All that ubuntu flattery makes me wonder if you're not lying that you use it, because if you did you'd know it has plenty of bugs and unpleasant behaviour like NOT reading the settings files from their location like it should but instead merrily applying things you don't wish it to, possibly held in some secret location nobody, not even their support, is privy to.To name but one thing.